Discussion Amir Khan vs. Kell Brook

Khan vs. Brook Winner and How?

  • Amir Khan Stoppage

    Votes: 2 6.7%
  • Amir Khan Decision

    Votes: 6 20.0%
  • Draw

    Votes: 2 6.7%
  • Kell Brook Decision

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kell Brook Stoppage

    Votes: 20 66.7%

  • Total voters
    30
Apr 19, 2014
6,536
2,368
Kells second best win is a guy who got schooled and stopped by Paul Malignaggi after Khan beat the fuck out of Paulie and made him look like an amateur for 10 rounds straight, and he (Kell) even got wobbled by him

You can't really argue the resumes, Khans is far, far, far superior both at first glance and when analysed in depth
 
Likes: NSFW
Oct 7, 2015
2,629
2,325
Khan only ever gave brook shit when he started shamelessly chasing khan while fighting bumm after bumm. Kell Brooks entire career is a joke
I don't believe that's true. However, I do think it's fair to say that his career is becoming a joke. His entire career hasn't been a joke, he has actually had a few decent fights but since he entered the world stage with his porter win he has wasted far too much time chasing khan when he could've fought good fighters and made money too. Someone like a broner could have been made imo. Many other fighters like that would have stepped in with brook while he held a title and it would have added some depth to his resume.
 
Oct 7, 2015
2,629
2,325
Wonder how quickly Eddie Hearn will change his "now or never" stance after the Crawford fight

I dont buy that Khan is scared of losing to Brook either, Khan thought hed beat Canelo ffs he thinks he'll beat Crawford theres no way he thinks he might lose to Brook
If he thinks he will lose or not is irrelevant. It's the fact that IF he did lose he wouldn't be able to take the shame of it. He's belittled brook for years and would look a fool if he lost to him by big KO, which is a big possibility. As it stands he can get KO'd by these p4p guys and get no stick because nobody expects him to do anything. He can also retire having never faced brook but will forever talk shit about brook not being in his level etc. The fight should have happened, now it won't which I believe is purely down to khan. It's a shame for the fans but since when do they matter in this sport?
 
If he thinks he will lose or not is irrelevant. It's the fact that IF he did lose he wouldn't be able to take the shame of it. He's belittled brook for years and would look a fool if he lost to him by big KO, which is a big possibility. As it stands he can get KO'd by these p4p guys and get no stick because nobody expects him to do anything. He can also retire having never faced brook but will forever talk shit about brook not being in his level etc. The fight should have happened, now it won't which I believe is purely down to khan. It's a shame for the fans but since when do they matter in this sport?
I agree if he did lose itd be tough for him but I just dont think Khan thinks like that, hes so ridiculously overconfident in himself.

Still think Khan Brook will happen anyway, itd make loadsamoney.
 
Likes: BoxSharp
If he thinks he will lose or not is irrelevant. It's the fact that IF he did lose he wouldn't be able to take the shame of it. He's belittled brook for years and would look a fool if he lost to him by big KO, which is a big possibility. As it stands he can get KO'd by these p4p guys and get no stick because nobody expects him to do anything. He can also retire having never faced brook but will forever talk shit about brook not being in his level etc. The fight should have happened, now it won't which I believe is purely down to khan. It's a shame for the fans but since when do they matter in this sport?
He owes the British boxing fans nothing, they’ve treated him like shit throughout this career so fuck em
 

steviebruno

CHB NYC Delegate
Jun 5, 2013
11,834
3,041
New York City
I don't believe that's true. However, I do think it's fair to say that his career is becoming a joke. His entire career hasn't been a joke, he has actually had a few decent fights but since he entered the world stage with his porter win he has wasted far too much time chasing khan when he could've fought good fighters and made money too. Someone like a broner could have been made imo. Many other fighters like that would have stepped in with brook while he held a title and it would have added some depth to his resume.
Eh... You're right, it's best we forget that he fought GGG and Spence while nearly losing his eye...
 
Oct 7, 2015
2,629
2,325
Eh... You're right, it's best we forget that he fought GGG and Spence while nearly losing his eye...
I'm saying he could have added depth to his resume. I'm as big a brook fan as any on here but you can't deny he's wasted a lot of time treading water and chasing khan. He had no business fighting GGG and it was a stupid reaction to khan fighting canelo. I give him credit for taking the Spence fight as it was a dangerous mandatory but let's be right, he's fought 2 world class welters and lost to 1.
 
Likes: The Kraken
Apr 19, 2014
6,536
2,368
Diaz pushed a close fight with an inexperienced Shawn Porter then got blitzed in the rematch. Diaz got absolutely destroyed by Thurman when they fought then. Porter has gone on to beat Danny Garcia a guy that flattened Khan. Fuck records Porter would destroy Khan and so would Brook. Now what’s your point?
Brooks resume is paper fucking thin and it's amazing people move the goal posts with Khan. Diaz beats Porter in most peoples minds and 'he pushed a close fight with an inexperienced Porter' Khan gets off the floor to beat him in his VERY NEXT fight and Khan was a glass chinned bum past his best who got dropped by a blown up shot Diaz who was never that good to begin with. Be fucking serious please. Breidis Prescott beat Khan and Abril, that must mean he was better than Brandon Rios and his resume is better than Khans? H2h right now means more than records? Porter is in his prime while Khan clearly isn't. Khan beat the fuck out of Barrera, must be a better fighter then
 

steviebruno

CHB NYC Delegate
Jun 5, 2013
11,834
3,041
New York City
I'm saying he could have added depth to his resume. I'm as big a brook fan as any on here but you can't deny he's wasted a lot of time treading water and chasing khan. He had no business fighting GGG and it was a stupid reaction to khan fighting canelo. I give him credit for taking the Spence fight as it was a dangerous mandatory but let's be right, he's fought 2 world class welters and lost to 1.
Why would Brook need to react to Khan getting brutally ko'd (again) by Canelo? Makes no sense at all. He simply assessed Errol Spence as a dangerous, low reward type of fight and wanted to secure a big payday before putting his title on the line. It was stupid, but the idea that it was in response to Khan humiliating himself (again) is even more stupid.
 

steviebruno

CHB NYC Delegate
Jun 5, 2013
11,834
3,041
New York City
Khan has Maidana, Kotelnik,Malignaggi before he was shot to shit, Alexander, Algieri, past it Collazo, past it Diaz right after he beat Porter in many peoples minds

Porter has Garcia, Broner, Alexander., shot to shit Malignaggi, shot to shit Berto

Brook has Porter, Senchenko (lol) Frankie Gavin?
Malignaggi "before he was shot" was already annihilated by Cotto and Hatton and beaten up by Juan Diaz.

Amir Khan's best win is Marcos Maidana, and he spent three rounds running away in that one. Literally running away.

The only difference between Khan and Brook is that Amir was far more hyped and was therefore placed in a better position to make bigger money fights. His overall resume is nothing special and would look very much like Kell's if he wasn't fighting on HBO out of the womb.
 
Last edited: