[Horse]

1. (1.) Carl Froch
2. (2.) Amir Khan
3. (3.) Ricky Burns
4. (4.) David Haye
5. (5.) Nathan Cleverly
6. (10.) Ola Afolabi
7. (6.) Brian Magee (Irish)
8. (7.) Kell Brook
9. (8.) Jamie McDonnell
10. (9.) Matthew Macklin

11. (11.) Andy Lee (Irish)
12. (12.) Kevin Mitchell
13. (13.) Rendall Munroe
14. (14.) Ryan Rhodes
15. (15.) George Groves
16. (16.) Tyson Fury
17. (17.) Darren Barker
18. (18.) Gavin Rees
19. (22.) Lee Selby
20. (20.) James DeGale

21. (21.) Tony Bellew
22. (23.) Martin Murray
23. (24.) Dereck Chisora
24. (25.) Kerry Hope
25. (26.) Derry Mathews
26. (NE.) David Price
27. (19.) Paul McCloskey (Irish)
28. (27.) Matthew Hatton
29. (28.) Scott Quigg
30. (29.) Gary Buckland

Out - (30.) John Murray

Any comments or criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

 

[doug.ie]

how far was carl frampton out of the list ?

 

[Horse]

how far was carl frampton out of the list ?

I generally don't rate beyond 30 but he would have been 31.

 

[doug.ie]

 

[doug.ie]

i'm not going to pick holes...not at all...i'll only confuse myself....but, macklin is a good bit above murray...you rate him as a good bit better ??

 

[Horse]

i'm not going to pick holes...not at all...i'll only confuse myself....but, macklin is a good bit above murray...you rate him as a good bit better ??

Macklin was far more competitive in his world title shots than Murray was in his.

 

[dkos]

What is the reasoning behind having Fury above the likes of Rees, Barker, Selby, and Bellew?

 

[Horse]

What is the reasoning behind having Fury above the likes of Rees, Barker, Selby, and Bellew?

I consider Fury's wins over Chisora and Rogan to be better than anything achieved by the fighters you mention.

 

[doug.ie]

I consider Fury's wins over Chisora and Rogan to be better than anything achieved by the fighters you mention.

above rees achievements ??

 

[dkos]

I consider Fury's wins over Chisora and Rogan to be better than anything achieved by the fighters you mention.

Honestly?

 

[JamieC]

Ye I agree, fury has some decent wins

 

[Horse]

above rees achievements ??

Perhaps I should have said RECENT achievements.

 

[dkos]

Chisora was in the worst shape of his career and you could have stuck a fork in Rogan two years ago.

How exactly do those two wins eclipse Selby's victories over Smith and Simpson, especially when you take into account the manner in which he did it?

 

[Noonaldinho]

I consider Fury's wins over Chisora and Rogan to be better than anything achieved by the fighters you mention.

Bellew who had a very debatable decision loss to your N0 5?

 

[084]

Agree with Kos, Selby should be alot higher,

 

[JamieC]

I'd switch macklin and Magee tbh, maybe that's just me but his win over sturm and very competitive bout with Martinez does it for me

 

[Horse]

Bellew who had a very debatable decision loss to your N0 5?

I don't consider Bellew's loss to Cleverley was "debatable" and prior to that he looked appalling against Ajisafe, got a dubious stoppage over McKenzie (after suffering two knockdowns) then ran for 12 rounds in his "masterclass" against McKenzie.

 

[Horse]

Chisora was in the worst shape of his career and you could have stuck a fork in Rogan two years ago.

How exactly do those two wins eclipse Selby's victories over Smith and Simpson, especially when you take into account the manner in which he did it?

Simpsons record in title fights is 4 - 7 - 0 Smith's only significant wins are over Simpson, Selby's wins over these two do not justify a higher rating in my opinion.

 

[Noonaldinho]

I don't consider Bellew's loss to Cleverley was "debatable" and prior to that he looked appalling against Ajisafe, got a dubious stoppage over McKenzie (after suffering two knockdowns) then ran for 12 rounds in his "masterclass" against McKenzie.

Ok, Clevs place at 5, who has he beat? Bellew is his standout win

 

[dkos]

Simpsons record in title fights is 4 - 7 - 0 Smith's only significant wins are over Simpson, Selby's wins over these two do not justify a higher rating in my opinion.

:lol:atsch

Should we just label you as a BoxRec Warrior now to save time for in the future?