[King Horse]

1. (1.) Carl Froch
2. (2.) Ricky Burns
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Amir Khan
5. (5.) Nathan Cleverly
6. (6.) Ola Afolabi
7. (7.) Kell Brook
8. (8.) Matthew Macklin
9. (9.) George Groves
10. (18.) Carl Frampton

11. (10.) Tyson Fury
12. (11.) Jamie McDonnell
13. (13.) Scott Quigg
14. (14.) James DeGale
15. (25.) Lee Selby
16. (12.) Gavin Rees
17. (15.) Darren Barker
18. (16.) Tony Bellew
19. (19.) Martin Murray
20. (20.) Gary Buckland

21. (24.) Andy Lee (Irish)
22. (28.) Kevin Satchell
23. (17.) David Price
24. (21.) Brian Magee (Irish)
25. (22.) Brian Rose
26. (23.) Frankie Gavin
27. (26.) Kevin Mitchell
28. (27.) Lee Haskins
29. (29.) Rendall Munroe
30. (30.) Dereck Chisora

 

[King Horse]

Any comments or criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

 

[Lunny]

Bellew's a bit low for me. Noiiiice list though, always find yours very agreeable for the most part.

 

[Vano-irons]

Not sure why i bother, but:

Price laid out in 2 by a 41 year old Thompson made famous by being KO'ed by Wlad twice. 23. Chisora loses to 2 of the best 3 HWs in the world. 30

Rees stopped by possibly the best lightweight on the planet, falls before Selby who outpoints Lindsey.

Satchell above Gavin I cannot possibly understand

 

[Roe]

:lol: Rendall Munroe still ranked.

 

[Vano-irons]

:lol: Rendall Munroe still ranked.

Don't get me started :lol:

Every month he asks for comments, and has never once changed any of the positions of fighters based of them.

 

[JamieC]

Ye @Vano-irons Gavin should be higher, Selby over Rees is controversial but being a massive Selby hugger I can live with it

 

[Roe]

People shouldn't get dropped in ratings for losing to higher level boxers. It should always be that simple for me.

Oh and people that retire shouldn't be rated.

 

[Vano-irons]

Selby has a lot of potential no doubt, but Rees has mixed at a higher level.

 

[King Horse]

Bellew's a bit low for me.

If he beats Chilemba this month then he will move a lot higher. At the moment I think Bellew's position is fair.

Noiiiice list though, always find yours very agreeable for the most part.

Thanks, Lunny. :good

 

[King Horse]

Not sure why i bother, but:

Price laid out in 2 by a 41 year old Thompson made famous by being KO'ed by Wlad twice. 23. Chisora loses to 2 of the best 3 HWs in the world. 30

Thompson was arguably a top 15 ranked heavyweight at the time. Chisora will overtake Price if he beats a half decent opponent in his next fight.

Rees stopped by possibly the best lightweight on the planet, falls before Selby who outpoints Lindsey.

He got stopped, so he dropped.

Satchell above Gavin I cannot possibly understand

Satchell just won a fight, so I moved him up a few places.

 

[dkos]

Yeah, and Satchell is also fighting in a division with less than ten recognised domestic fighters...

 

[Vano-irons]

:lol: Chisora lost to fighters positioned 2 and 3 on most people's rankings.

Again, the list doesn't make sense to me. But there's no point having a debate as you refuse to change anything every time. I think you just want people to say 'hey, nice list' over and over

 

[King Horse]

Ye @Vano-irons Gavin should be higher, Selby over Rees is controversial but being a massive Selby hugger I can live with it

Gavin could easily be a few places higher, but I don't think he should be too much higher like being in the top 20 yet.

Selby has clearly beaten the three next best featherweights in Britain (Smith, Simpson & Lindsay) and established himself as the clear British No. 1. Rees hasn't fought any of the other top four British lightweights (Burns, Mitchell & Murray) and has only fought one top five British fighter (Mathews).

 

[King Horse]

People shouldn't get dropped in ratings for losing to higher level boxers. It should always be that simple for me.

If they get demolished they should.

 

[Roe]

Thompson was arguably a top 15 ranked heavyweight at the time. Chisora will overtake Price if he beats a half decent opponent in his next fight.

Followed by..

He got stopped, so he dropped.

:lol:

Still makes no sense. How do you think Selby would get on against Broner right now? How can you punish fighters for trying to take steps up?

 

[JamieC]

Still makes no sense. How do you think Selby would get on against Broner right now? How can you punish fighters for trying to take steps up?

Selby aaaalllll day :deal

 

[King Horse]

Selby has a lot of potential no doubt, but Rees has mixed at a higher level.

How much better is M'baye than Selby's best wins?

That win was over 5.5 years ago and none of Rees' other wins are clearly better than Selby's.

 

[dkos]

Can you just try and explain why Satchell is ranked so high?

 

[King Horse]

Yeah, and Satchell is also fighting in a division with less than ten recognised domestic fighters...

Satchell has beaten the best domestic opponents that were available in his shallow weight division.

Gavin has plenty of good domestic opponents to choose from, so he should get a move on and fight them and then he can fly past Satchell P4P.