Ok so this is something i've been working on for a while across each division. I basically go through boxing history and decide who I personally feel was the best of the divisions claimants at any given time. This isn't to be confused with linearity or h2h but rather who I felt was beating the best people in the best fashion at any given time.
The premiere fighter can lose that title if someone else comes along beating better people (i.e. whilst Johnson went inactive, Langford battered the top 5 list on a monthly basis).
Usually if a guy has been inactive for more than a year I'll look for a replacement unless that guys has been seeking fights (i.e. the confusion between Braddock facing Schmelling or Louis means he gets a pass for his inactivity whereas Dempsey flitting off to Hollywood doesn't and when Wills beat Firpo I considered him to have become the premiere fighter).
I also treat my own scores as gospel. By that I mean because I felt that Lewis beat Holyfield first time round, he took his crown in March. If there's a controversial fight I haven't watched fully, I'll usually consider it a draw, with Johnson v Hart being the sole exception as I think the reports are consistent in that Johnson was the cleaner more effective fighter and Hart was the more aggressive and I know which style I prefer 10/10 (Louis - Walcott 1, Schmelling - Sharkey 2 etc).
The #ONO means number of notable opponents. That being I look at the guys a man fought whilst I considered him premiere and listed all of the notable opponents without giving duplicate scores (so Langford gets 7 notable opponents rather than 17 notable fights)
I actually have an interim timeline for all 18 divisions but I reckon this is my final HW list so decided I'd post it considering I'm pretty happy with it.
apologies for it not reading very well but the conversion from Exel to CHB isn't something i'm very good at and it's far too much effort for me to go through putting spaces etc.
Name-Reign-Reason it ended-# of notable opponents faced
John L Sullivan - Jul 1882 to Apr 1889- Jackson beat Cardiff - 9
Peter Jackson - Apr 1889 to Sep 1892- Corbett beat Sullivan- 8
James Corbett - Sep 1892 to Feb 1896- Fitzsimmons beat Maher- 1
Bob Fitzsimmons - Feb 1896 to Jun 1899- Lost- 2
James Jeffries - Jun 1899 to Mar 1905- Johnson "beat" Hart- 5
Jack Johnson - Mar 1905 to Dec 1911- McVea beat Langford- 10
Sam McVea - Dec 1911 to Apr 1912- Lost- 0
Sam Langford - Apr 1912 to Apr 1915- Willard beat Johnson- 7
Jess Willard - Apr 1915 to Apr 1918- Wills beat Langford- 1
Harry to Wills- Apr 1918 to Jul 1919- Dempsey beat Willard- 2
Jack Dempsey- Jul 1919 to Sep 1924- Wills beat Firpo- 5
Harry Wills- Sep 1924 to Sep 1926- Tunney beat Dempsey- 2
Gene Tunney- Sep 1926 to Sep 1929- Sharkey beat Loughran- 2
Jack Sharkey- Sep 1929 to Jun 1930- Lost- 1
Max Schmelling- Jun 1930 to Jun 1933- Lost- 3
Max Baer- Jun 1933 to Jun 1935- Lost- 2
James Braddock-Jun 1935 to Jun 1937- Lost- 0
Joe Louis- Jun 1937 to Sep 1942- Bivins beat Mauriello- 15
Jimmy Bivins - Sep 1942 to Feb 1946- Lost- 13
Jersey Joe Walcott - Feb 1946 to Jun 1946- Louis beat Conn- 1
Joe Louis- Jun 1946 to Jun 1949- Charles beat Walcott- 2
Ezzard Charles- Jun 1949 to Jul 1951- Lost- 8
Jersey Joe Walcott- Jul 1951 to Sep 1952- Lost- 1
Rocky Marciano- Sep 1952 to Nov 1956- Patterson beat Moore- 5
Floyd Patterson- Nov 1956 to Jun 1959- Lost- 3
Ingo Johanneson- Jun 1959 to Jun 1960- Lost- 0
Floyd Patterson- Jun 1960 to Sep 1962- Lost- 1
Sonny Liston- Sep 1962 to Feb 1964- Lost- 1
Muhammad Ali- Feb 1964 to Mar 1968- Frazier beat Mathis- 9
Joe Frazier- Mar 1968 to Jan 1973- Lost- 6
George Foreman- Jan 1973 to Oct 1974- Lost- 2
Muhammad Ali- Oct 1974 to Apr 1976- "Lost"- 4
Jimmy Young - Apr 1976 to Nov 1977- Lost- 2
Ken Norton - Nov 1977 to Jun 1978- Lost- 0
Larry Holmes- Jun 1978 to Sep 1985- Lost- 17
Michael Spinks- Sep 1985 to Apr 1986- "Lost"- 0
Larry Holmes- Apr 1986 to Nov 1986- Tyson beat Berbick- 0
Mike Tyson- Nov 1986 to Feb 1990- Lost- 9
Buster Douglas- Feb 1990 to Oct 1990- Lost- 0
Evander Holyfield- Oct 1990 to Nov 1992- Lost- 2
Riddick Bowe- Nov 1992 to Mar 1996- Tyson beat Bruno- 5
Mike Tyson- Mar 1996 to Nov 1996- Lost- 1
Evander Holyfield- Nov 1996 to Mar 1999-"Lost"- 2
Lennox Lewis- Mar 1999 to Apr 2001- Lost- 4
Hasim Rahman-Apr 2001 to Nov 2001- Lost- 0
Lennox Lewis- Nov 2001 to Mar 2004- Vitali beat Sanders- 2
Vitali Klitschko- Mar 2004 to Apr 2006- Wlad beat Byrd- 1
Wlad Klitschko- Apr 2006 to Jun 2012- Still Going- 10
The premiere fighter can lose that title if someone else comes along beating better people (i.e. whilst Johnson went inactive, Langford battered the top 5 list on a monthly basis).
Usually if a guy has been inactive for more than a year I'll look for a replacement unless that guys has been seeking fights (i.e. the confusion between Braddock facing Schmelling or Louis means he gets a pass for his inactivity whereas Dempsey flitting off to Hollywood doesn't and when Wills beat Firpo I considered him to have become the premiere fighter).
I also treat my own scores as gospel. By that I mean because I felt that Lewis beat Holyfield first time round, he took his crown in March. If there's a controversial fight I haven't watched fully, I'll usually consider it a draw, with Johnson v Hart being the sole exception as I think the reports are consistent in that Johnson was the cleaner more effective fighter and Hart was the more aggressive and I know which style I prefer 10/10 (Louis - Walcott 1, Schmelling - Sharkey 2 etc).
The #ONO means number of notable opponents. That being I look at the guys a man fought whilst I considered him premiere and listed all of the notable opponents without giving duplicate scores (so Langford gets 7 notable opponents rather than 17 notable fights)
I actually have an interim timeline for all 18 divisions but I reckon this is my final HW list so decided I'd post it considering I'm pretty happy with it.
apologies for it not reading very well but the conversion from Exel to CHB isn't something i'm very good at and it's far too much effort for me to go through putting spaces etc.
Name-Reign-Reason it ended-# of notable opponents faced
John L Sullivan - Jul 1882 to Apr 1889- Jackson beat Cardiff - 9
Peter Jackson - Apr 1889 to Sep 1892- Corbett beat Sullivan- 8
James Corbett - Sep 1892 to Feb 1896- Fitzsimmons beat Maher- 1
Bob Fitzsimmons - Feb 1896 to Jun 1899- Lost- 2
James Jeffries - Jun 1899 to Mar 1905- Johnson "beat" Hart- 5
Jack Johnson - Mar 1905 to Dec 1911- McVea beat Langford- 10
Sam McVea - Dec 1911 to Apr 1912- Lost- 0
Sam Langford - Apr 1912 to Apr 1915- Willard beat Johnson- 7
Jess Willard - Apr 1915 to Apr 1918- Wills beat Langford- 1
Harry to Wills- Apr 1918 to Jul 1919- Dempsey beat Willard- 2
Jack Dempsey- Jul 1919 to Sep 1924- Wills beat Firpo- 5
Harry Wills- Sep 1924 to Sep 1926- Tunney beat Dempsey- 2
Gene Tunney- Sep 1926 to Sep 1929- Sharkey beat Loughran- 2
Jack Sharkey- Sep 1929 to Jun 1930- Lost- 1
Max Schmelling- Jun 1930 to Jun 1933- Lost- 3
Max Baer- Jun 1933 to Jun 1935- Lost- 2
James Braddock-Jun 1935 to Jun 1937- Lost- 0
Joe Louis- Jun 1937 to Sep 1942- Bivins beat Mauriello- 15
Jimmy Bivins - Sep 1942 to Feb 1946- Lost- 13
Jersey Joe Walcott - Feb 1946 to Jun 1946- Louis beat Conn- 1
Joe Louis- Jun 1946 to Jun 1949- Charles beat Walcott- 2
Ezzard Charles- Jun 1949 to Jul 1951- Lost- 8
Jersey Joe Walcott- Jul 1951 to Sep 1952- Lost- 1
Rocky Marciano- Sep 1952 to Nov 1956- Patterson beat Moore- 5
Floyd Patterson- Nov 1956 to Jun 1959- Lost- 3
Ingo Johanneson- Jun 1959 to Jun 1960- Lost- 0
Floyd Patterson- Jun 1960 to Sep 1962- Lost- 1
Sonny Liston- Sep 1962 to Feb 1964- Lost- 1
Muhammad Ali- Feb 1964 to Mar 1968- Frazier beat Mathis- 9
Joe Frazier- Mar 1968 to Jan 1973- Lost- 6
George Foreman- Jan 1973 to Oct 1974- Lost- 2
Muhammad Ali- Oct 1974 to Apr 1976- "Lost"- 4
Jimmy Young - Apr 1976 to Nov 1977- Lost- 2
Ken Norton - Nov 1977 to Jun 1978- Lost- 0
Larry Holmes- Jun 1978 to Sep 1985- Lost- 17
Michael Spinks- Sep 1985 to Apr 1986- "Lost"- 0
Larry Holmes- Apr 1986 to Nov 1986- Tyson beat Berbick- 0
Mike Tyson- Nov 1986 to Feb 1990- Lost- 9
Buster Douglas- Feb 1990 to Oct 1990- Lost- 0
Evander Holyfield- Oct 1990 to Nov 1992- Lost- 2
Riddick Bowe- Nov 1992 to Mar 1996- Tyson beat Bruno- 5
Mike Tyson- Mar 1996 to Nov 1996- Lost- 1
Evander Holyfield- Nov 1996 to Mar 1999-"Lost"- 2
Lennox Lewis- Mar 1999 to Apr 2001- Lost- 4
Hasim Rahman-Apr 2001 to Nov 2001- Lost- 0
Lennox Lewis- Nov 2001 to Mar 2004- Vitali beat Sanders- 2
Vitali Klitschko- Mar 2004 to Apr 2006- Wlad beat Byrd- 1
Wlad Klitschko- Apr 2006 to Jun 2012- Still Going- 10