Boxing Forums banner

Who wins?

  • Brook Decision

  • Brook Stoppage

  • Draw

  • Spence Decision

  • Spence Stoppage

161 - 180 of 453 Posts
Discussion starter · #161 ·
I don't think the criticism was anywhere near vocal enough to force this fight to happen, it's happening because Brook wants to fight the best. Golovkin and now a hot prospect in Spence he could have easily skipped over. About time people got off his back, especially since it's questionable how easily he can make the weight now. Kudos to Brook, I'm favouring Spence ever so slightly at the moment.
Brook was looking to fight Khan, Pacquiao and canelo before he was just left with Spence. I understand the risk/reward and tons of props to Kell for taking the fight. This just wasn't his first choice
 
I don't think the criticism was anywhere near vocal enough to force this fight to happen, it's happening because Brook wants to fight the best. Golovkin and now a hot prospect in Spence he could have easily skipped over. About time people got off his back, especially since it's questionable how easily he can make the weight now. Kudos to Brook, I'm favouring Spence ever so slightly at the moment.
I think the reprehensible treatment they would have recieved if they avoided Spence, was enough to convince them to take the fight. Khan dangled the carrot at 147, which made everyone rightfully pull Brook / Hearn up on the Spence issue. If you're okay to fight Khan and Pac at 147, then you should also be okay take on the first decent mandatory that you're being asked of. It's very clear, even by their own admission, that this isn't their first choice.
 
I think the reprehensible treatment they would have recieved if they avoided Spence, was enough to convince them to take the fight. Khan dangled the carrot at 147, which made everyone rightfully pull Brook / Hearn up on the Spence issue. If you're okay to fight Khan and Pac at 147, then you should also be okay take on the first decent mandatory that you're being asked of. It's very clear, even by their own admission, that this isn't their first choice.
Hate to say it but it would have been a small but very vocal part of the boxing community that would have kicked up a fuss, something that Hearn has proven not to give a shit about for the most part. Hearn would have been happy to bypass Spence, I feel this fight is happening because Brook genuinely wants the challenge. I don't think the khan fight was unacceptable, what was unacceptable was how long Spence was forced into limbo waiting for something to happen. The negotiations for that fight went on far far too long.
 
May is going to be nice, we got the Canelo vs Julito Megafight, then we got this one a couple weeks after.

:happy:bbb
 
  • Like
Reactions: church11
I think Spence takes it too. Brook is good, but Spence is the real deal. I could be wrong, but I'm glad we'll get to find out soon!
This.

Also, two factors that might negatively affect Brook:

1: He's really too big now for the division, and so might be a little drained.

2: The loss to golovkin, even though expected and with all the caveats, may have put a small chip on his shoulder. He doesn't really have anything to prove to the world, but he may feel that way, regardless. Thus, he may take foolish chances, trying desperately to put Spence away, and that would be a huge mistake.
 
Discussion starter · #177 ·
I really need to sit down and think about this fight. I'm trying to envision what will happen. I'm thinking Brook will win the first 2 rounds close with Spence looking to box a little more. Then he'll start landing more and more body punches and start to really turn on the heat as the fight goes on. Spence's power has really developed over his career. Before he'd slowly break you down and force stoppage. Now he's getting 1 punch KOs on guys who never been stopped even against the elite punchers of the division
 
I really need to sit down and think about this fight. I'm trying to envision what will happen. I'm thinking Brook will win the first 2 rounds close with Spence looking to box a little more. Then he'll start landing more and more body punches and start to really turn on the heat as the fight goes on. Spence's power has really developed over his career. Before he'd slowly break you down and force stoppage. Now he's getting 1 punch KOs on guys who never been stopped even against the elite punchers of the division
I guess if the fight takes place in the UK, the British judging will have to be taken into account as well. Any close rounds will go to Brook. Spence is gonna have to make sure he clearly wins some early rounds, and potentially get the KO, to avoid any controversy.
 
Spence is definitely gonna' need the KO to win here. The close rounds are almost certainly gonna' go to Brook. Brook, as an investment and with potential fights with Khan on the line, is gonna' have insurance.

I can't wait for this. Difficult to predict, too. Spence has always been vulnerable to straight rights and uppercuts, and so Brook's Chocolate Brownie may have a joyful night. But at the same time, Brook's always looked shaky at 147 and, unlike Carson Jones and Shenchenko, Spence is a ruthless finisher when he has people hurt.

Questions that we've always asked of both fighters, will finally be answered. That's what makes this such a great fight.
 
161 - 180 of 453 Posts